This Is Why SMS Doesn’t Work for You

Hello! You've arrived at What Actually Works 🤓

We break down the real strategies, decisions, and plays that actually move the needle in your marketing, and here it for today.

---

😅This Is Why SMS Doesn’t Work for You

A pet food brand and a furniture brand can run identical SMS programs and one will compound month over month while the other flatlines after the first few flows. The difference isn’t execution. It’s category mechanics. Most brands find this out after six months of mediocre numbers. The ones who understand it upfront build their entire program around it from day one.

The Repurchase Decision Has Two Modes

Some customers repurchase on autopilot. The decision is made before they hear from you. SMS in these categories isn’t persuasion, it’s a timing mechanism. Show up at the exact moment the mental trigger fires, before they drift to Amazon instead.

Other customers re-convince themselves every cycle. A premium supplement. A $200 skincare set. The repurchase is a fresh evaluation every time. “Time to reorder” has nothing to tap into. You’re starting from zero persuasion each cycle.

Most brands build one SMS program and apply it to both. That’s why half of all SMS programs underperform.

When There’s a Reflex, Time It Individually

For replenishment categories, stop using average category windows and start using individual consumption gaps:

• Calculate the days between each customer’s first and second order
• Use that personal window as the trigger for every message after it
• The 22-day repurchaser gets touched at day 20. The 45-day repurchaser doesn’t hear from you until day 42.

Running email and SMS on separate platforms makes this impossible to execute cleanly. Omnisend puts both in one workflow so replenishment flows adapt to individual behavior without two disconnected data sets. Brands on Omnisend average 73x ROI across combined flows.

When There’s No Reflex, Build One

For categories where repurchase requires active re-persuasion, the copy strategy changes entirely:

• Stop leading with the product, lead with the result
• A supplement brand texting “time to reorder” is fishing with no bait
• The same brand texting what customers who complete 60 days actually experience gives the subscriber a reason to re-commit to the identity they bought into originally
• They’re not rebuying a supplement. They’re rebuying a version of themselves.

Map the emotional reason behind the first purchase. Build your SMS calendar around reinforcing that identity, not reminding them of the transaction.

The Diagnostic Most Brands Skip

Pull your opt-out rate by customer segment, not by campaign:

• Opt-outs spiking among two-time buyers means your SMS is interrupting a reflex that was working without you
• Opt-outs spiking after the first message to one-time buyers means your identity hook isn’t landing

Either way the pattern tells you exactly which half of this to fix first.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

---

Partnership with Templafy

Your team is prompting AI decks. Your brand has no idea.

Every presentation your team generates without guardrails is a brand liability waiting to happen.

Templafy works inside PowerPoint. You set the brand rules, approved assets, and content guardrails once. Every AI-generated deck your team builds after that follows them automatically.

• Brand rules are enforced on every AI-generated deck
• Client-ready presentations that are on-message by default
• 4M+ users at Adobe, KPMG, and Pandora are already running on it

BDO saved $1.65M in a year. Adobe teams got back 72% of their time. Your brand shows up right, every time, without you having to police it.

---

🐥 Tweet Worth Saving

---

Thanks for being part of the WAW team 💃 We’d love to know if this was helpful so we can continue playing it smart with the right strategies.