Your best customers went quiet
🔕 Customers who used to order often and then stopped are the most valuable people to reach before Black Friday crowds the inbox, and more!

Hello! You've arrived at What Actually Works 🤓
We break down the real strategies, decisions, and plays that actually move the needle in your marketing, and here it for today.
🔕 Win back lapsed regulars in the next four weeks, before BFCM drowns them out
Every store has a group that used to order every few weeks and then stopped. They don't show up in a standard win-back flow, because those usually trigger on time since the last order and treat a five-time buyer like a one-time buyer.
In November, your message to them competes with every Black Friday email in their inbox. Late October is the quieter window.
Find them
Filter for customers who:
- Placed four or more orders
- Ordered at least once in the six months before their last order
- Haven't ordered in the last 120 days
That definition is my judgment. Adjust the 120 days to roughly twice your typical reorder interval.
Week of October 26: Ask, don't sell
Send a short, plain email from a real person: "You used to order regularly and we noticed you stopped. Was something wrong?" Add three reply buttons: "Found something else," "Didn't need more," and "Had a problem."
The answers tell you what to send next.
Week of November 2: Answer the reason
- Found something else: show what's changed since they left, such as a new formula, size, or price.
- Didn't need more: invite them to set up a reminder or subscription.
- Had a problem: have support reach out personally, with no offer attached.
The value of starting from purchase history shows in one agency's BFCM result. Enflow Digital used Omnisend's segmentation and AI connection to map a skincare client's purchase patterns in minutes, then sent a single plain-text offer to 1,676 customers with at least four orders. It brought in nearly $18,000, beating the previous month's broad campaigns combined. You can see the full story.
Week of November 9: Offer something personal
Make an email-only offer for this group, sized to what they used to spend. A gift with their usual order often works better than a discount, in my judgment.
Week of November 16: Fold them into BFCM
Anyone who came back joins your loyal BFCM segment. Anyone who didn't respond gets the standard sale emails, then moves into a slower cadence after Cyber Monday.
What to measure
Count reactivated customers, their revenue through December and the share who order again within 90 days. A one-off return driven by a discount is worth less than a customer who restarts their habit.
Omnisend runs email and SMS for over 150,000 ecommerce brands. Migration is free and takes up to five business days. Check out Omnisend here.
Run the filter and count the group. Even a few hundred lapsed regulars can be worth more than a broad BFCM send.
Partnership with HubSpot
Your AI doesn't know your business. HubSpot does.

Your team already uses their preferred AI tools. But when those tools only see what you paste into a conversation, you’re left moving business context in and carrying answers back out. There’s a more connected way to work.
On November 5th, join HubSpot for a live webinar to see how it connects with the AI you already use, grounding every answer in real context about your business. Ask questions, take action, and update your CRM without switching out of the conversation.
You’ll also learn about HubSpot’s headless product strategy and how to connect Claude, ChatGPT, or another preferred AI assistant while keeping control through built-in governance.
HubSpot is the only CRM designed to work wherever you do, and the #1 CRM connector in Claude and ChatGPT. Discover how to get more from your AI today.
Reserve your webinar spot and join HubSpot’s product team for an AMA.
Can't attend the session live? Register anyway, and you’ll get the recordings in 24 hours.
🐥 Tweet Worth Saving

🥳 Events
🔥 What High-Growth Brands Are Doing Beyond Meta Right Now
October 29 | The Glasshouse, NYC | Free In-Person Event
See how leading teams are expanding acquisition through TV, Reddit, and other channels without losing revenue accountability. Hear directly from Reddit CEO Steve Huffman, Cody Plofker, and growth leaders already making these trade-offs at scale.
Thanks for being part of the WAW team 💃 We’d love to know if this was helpful so we can continue playing it smart with the right strategies.