Turn comments into email signups

🎬 Give viewers a reason to watch before asking for a keyword comment, then test which placement brings in subscribers, and more!

Hello! You've arrived at What Actually Works 🤓

We break down the real strategies, decisions, and plays that actually move the needle in your marketing, and here it for today.


🎬 Three plays to turn keyword comments into email signups

Black Friday Reels are full of "comment DEAL below." That ask can backfire. Instagram head Adam Mosseri named the three signals that matter most for ranking: watch time, likes, and sends. Comments weren't in his top three, but that doesn't mean asking for them reduces reach. Try showing the product payoff before the spoken ask, then check whether viewers keep watching and sign up. Examples are illustrative.

Play 1: Earn the watch, then ask

Run it if: your Reels lose most viewers in the first five seconds.

Lead with the product doing its thing. Put the keyword on screen as small text from the start, so early leavers still see it, but save the spoken ask for after the payoff.

  • Seconds 0 to 3: the result, the before-and-after or the price drop.
  • Seconds 3 to 12: proof, close-ups, a real reaction.
  • Final 3 seconds: "Comment DEAL to join our email list and get the code."

Set up the reply and offer delivery before posting. Omnisend's Social Capture, available on any paid plan, automatically DMs people who comment your keyword and asks for their email. Only those who reply with a valid email address join your list. Make the email sign-up clear in the DM and set up a welcome automation to deliver the promised code. 

You can turn your followers into subscribers. Then compare watch time with your last five Reels of similar length and topic, alongside the email signups collected. If watch time drops, test moving the ask later; the drop alone doesn't tell you what caused it.

Play 2: Make the keyword worth sending

Run it if: your product is often bought as a gift.

Sends made Mosseri's top three. So write a reason to forward the Reel and a reason to comment, both in one line: "Send this to whoever's hard to shop for, then comment GIFT for 15% off." One viewer shares, the friend comments, and you reach someone your follower graph wouldn't.

Play 3: Pin the ask, keep the caption clean

Run it if: your captions run longer than two lines.

Start the caption with the hook and keep the keyword out of it. Post your own comment with the keyword and pin it, so it sits at the top of the thread where people can copy it. Commenters see the instruction, and the caption stays readable. Pin a fresh comment on every new Reel, since pins stay with their post.

Final whistle

Before your next Reel, make sure viewers see the payoff before the spoken ask. Use the timings above as an illustrative starting point, then adjust based on watch time and email signups.


Partnership with AirOps

Could Your Reporting Get the Wrong Channel Cut?

AI search could influence a buyer long before a sale shows up in your reports. If that influence goes uncredited, you could cut spending on a channel that’s helping customers choose you.

On November 20 at 2 PM ET, get inside the measurement work with Google Meridian creator Hitesh Wadhwani, Paramark CEO Pranav Piyush, and AirOps’ COO Matt Hammel.

They’ll break down the blind spots that could be steering your spend:

  • Understand where AI search attribution falls short before treating low tracked results as a reason to cut.
  • Learn the three requirements for credible measurement so you can spot what your provider’s reporting is missing.
  • Explore how AI search fits into existing marketing mix models alongside the channels competing for your budget.

Take the gaps in your reporting back to your team before they become cuts in your budget.

Can't attend the session live? Register anyway, and you’ll get the recordings within 24 hours.


🐥 Tweet Worth Saving


Thanks for being part of the WAW team 💃 We’d love to know if this was helpful so we can continue playing it smart with the right strategies.

Subscribe to What Actually Works

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe