Noindex your shared pages

πŸ” Google updated its spam guidance on user-generated content, telling sites to keep pages made for sharing or utility out of search results, and more!

Hello! You've arrived at What Actually Works πŸ€“

We break down the real strategies, decisions, and plays that actually move the needle in your marketing, and here it for today.


πŸ” Two defensive plays and one offensive play for Google's user content guidance

Search Google for your domain plus the word "casino." If anything comes back, spammers have found a page on your site they can write on.

On October 26, Google updated its guidance on user-generated spam. It recommends noindex on pages built for sharing or utility, verifying your site in Search Console so you get alerts, and watching for unusual spikes in indexed pages or traffic.

For a store, user-created pages include wishlists, shared carts, public profiles, Q&A, and community posts. Open pages like these let spammers publish their own links and keywords on your domain. Start on defense, then move to offense.

Defense play 1: Seal the shared pages

Run it if: customers can create anything with their own URL.

Skip it if: they can't create public pages at all.

  1. List features that create pages: wishlists, registries, profiles, Q&A, forums.
  2. Search your domain plus words you'd never use, such as "casino" or "loan."
  3. Add noindex to page types that exist for sharing, such as shared carts and wishlists.
  4. Confirm the change with URL inspection in Search Console.

Defense play 2: Set a tripwire

Run it if: you run open community or review features.

Skip it if: all user content is reviewed before it goes live.

  1. Verify your site in Search Console if you haven't.
  2. Check indexed pages weekly.
  3. If indexed pages jump more than 20% in a week with no launch to explain it, investigate. That threshold is my judgment.

Offense play: Keep the good user content working

Run it if: you have product reviews or genuine customer Q&A.

Reviews and real answers help buyers and often help search. Keep them indexed on product pages, where they support the sale, and moderate them instead of hiding them. The goal is removing pages made for sharing, while keeping content that helps someone decide.

What cleanup looks like

A store with 3,000 product and category pages finds 9,000 indexed URLs. 5,500 are public wishlists, many stuffed with spam text. After noindex, those drop out over time, and real pages make up far more of what Google sees. These figures are illustrative.

Keep an eye on

  • Spam terms appearing in Search Console queries
  • Spikes from user-generated URL paths
  • Security notices from Google

Before the next whistle

Run that "casino" search now. It takes a minute, and it tells you whether this is a cleanup job or a ten-minute settings check.


Partnership with New Engen

Your next winning ad needs a different voice 

Your product solves a real problem. But when every ad makes a promise, buyers need a reason to believe yours. 

A qualified expert explaining how it works can give them that reason.

Grapevine, now part of New Engen, creates ads delivered through creator and publisher handles with production managed from brief to launch.

You approve the angles and ship product. Grapevine sources creators, handles briefs and payments, then produces and posts the content.

  • Madison Reed achieved 20% efficiencies over target CPA and 50% higher LTV.
  • Mathnasium cut Meta CPL by 33% in under 30 days.
  • Cirkul achieved 15-50% lower TikTok CPA and nearly doubled CTR through creator whitelisting.

Put this approach to work with your first campaign on Grapevine.

Kick off by November 30 and your first campaign is free: 8 statics and 1 article worth $1,500.


πŸ₯ Tweet Worth Saving


πŸ’ƒEvents

πŸ”₯ What the Creator of Google Meridian Looks at Before Moving Budget

November 20 | 2 PM ET | Virtual Event

Hitesh Wadhwani, creator of Google Meridian, breaks down how to judge AI search when last-click attribution misses the influence. Learn which exposure signals matter, how recommendations should be valued, and what evidence your team should demand before the next budget review.

βœ… Reserve Your Free Seat

Can't attend the session live? Register anyway, and you’ll get the recordings in 24 hours.


Thanks for being part of the WAW team πŸ’ƒ We’d love to know if this was helpful so we can continue playing it smart with the right strategies.

Subscribe to What Actually Works

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
jamie@example.com
Subscribe